Skip to content

- Edgar Allan Poe

For her this rhyme is penned, whose luminous eyes,

Brightly expressive as the twins of Leda,

Shall find her own sweet name, that, nestling lies

Upon the page, enwrapped from every reader.

...

Read full poem

verb

To accept something as true; feel sure of the truth of.

I believe that honesty is the best policy, even when it's difficult.

Know more
567 words~3 min read

The Gatekeeper's Impossible Question

At the edge of the known world, where the last road crumbled into dust, stood a gate of twisted iron. Beyond it lay the Valley of Answers, a place whispered about in every village. But no one had ever passed through the gate, for it was guarded by an old woman known only as the Gatekeeper. She wore a cloak of grey feathers and carried a staff carved from a single piece of bone. Her eyes were pale, like winter sky, and she never smiled. Each traveler who arrived was asked the same impossible question: "What is the one thing that cannot be taken, yet can be given?" Those who answered wrongly were turned away, their memories of the journey fading like morning mist.

The archetype of the Gatekeeper appears in stories across many cultures. She is the threshold guardian, the one who tests the hero before they can enter a new world. In this tale, the gate is not just a physical barrier but a symbol of the boundary between ignorance and understanding. The setting—a barren road ending at a lonely gate—creates a sense of isolation and challenge. The audience, Year 7 readers, can recognize this pattern from other myths: the sphinx in Greek stories, the ferryman in Chinese legends, or the old woman in Baba Yaga's hut. Each version teaches that the journey inward is as important as the journey outward.

Many travelers tried to answer the Gatekeeper's question. A wealthy merchant offered gold, saying, "Wealth cannot be taken, yet can be given." The Gatekeeper shook her head. A scholar recited, "Knowledge cannot be taken, yet can be given." Still she refused. A warrior claimed, "Honour cannot be taken, yet can be given." The Gatekeeper remained silent. Each time, the traveler was sent back down the road, their confidence broken. The question seemed impossible because it asked for something that was both permanent and transferable, a paradox that twisted the mind. The villagers began to believe the gate was a trick, a cruel joke with no answer.

The audience, Year 7 readers, can recognize this pattern from other myths: the sphinx in Greek stories, the ferryman in Chinese legends, or the old woman in Baba Yaga's hut.

One day, a young girl named Elara arrived at the gate. She was not rich, clever, or strong. She carried only a small bundle of bread and a jug of water. When the Gatekeeper asked her the question, Elara thought for a long moment. Then she replied, "A promise. A promise cannot be taken from you by force, yet you can give it freely to another. And once given, it binds you." The Gatekeeper's expression softened. She stepped aside and pushed the gate open. "You have answered correctly," she said. "A promise is the thread that holds the world together. Enter the valley, but remember: every promise you make here will echo beyond the gate."

Elara walked through into a land of rolling green hills and clear streams. She understood that the Gatekeeper's question was not a riddle to be solved but a test of character. The archetype of the threshold guardian had taught her that true worth is not measured by wealth, knowledge, or strength, but by the integrity of one's word. The setting—the lonely gate at the edge of the world—symbolised the moment of choice we all face. For the audience, this story invites reflection on the promises we make and keep. It shows that the most impossible questions often have the simplest answers, if we are willing to look inside ourselves.