Reading Willow Persuasive Writing & Essays Library
A curated collection of persuasive texts and essay models exploring argument structure, rhetorical technique, and critical reasoning — ideal for developing analytical reading and writing skills across all year levels.
Against Clear Labels on AI-Generated Content
The proposition that all AI-generated content should be clearly labelled appears, at first glance, to be an unassailable defence of transparency. Who could oppose letting readers know whether a text w...
Should Students Get Free Public Transport?
The question of whether students should receive free public transport is more than a budgetary debate; it is a test of a society's commitment to equitable education. Access to schooling should not hin...
Should Social Media Require Verified Age Checks?
Social media platforms have become central to modern life, yet their design often prioritises engagement over safety. The question of whether they should be required to implement verified age checks i...
Should Phones Be Locked Away During Class?
Phones should be locked away during class because attention is one of the most valuable resources in education. A lesson cannot succeed if students are physically present but mentally pulled toward me...
The Case Against Universal Basic Income
In recent years, the concept of Universal Basic Income (UBI) has gained traction among policymakers and intellectuals as a panacea for economic inequality and technological unemployment. Proponents ar...
For Later School Start Times
The debate over school start times has intensified in recent years, with mounting evidence suggesting that early morning bells are detrimental to adolescent health and academic performance. Despite th...
Against School Uniforms
The debate over mandatory school uniforms often polarises opinion, but a careful examination of the evidence suggests that the case against them is stronger. While proponents argue that uniforms promo...
Against Limits on Weekend Homework
The debate over whether homework should be limited on weekends has intensified as educators and parents weigh the benefits of academic momentum against the need for rest. While some argue that student...
Against Daily Reading Time in Every Class
The proposal that every class should dedicate a fixed period to daily reading time has gained traction among educators and parents alike. Proponents argue that such a routine fosters a love of literat...
Against Stricter Biometric Surveillance Limits
In an era defined by unprecedented security challenges and the rapid evolution of digital infrastructure, the call to impose stricter limits on biometric surveillance has gained considerable traction...
For Learning First Aid
The question of whether first aid should be a compulsory component of the school curriculum is one that elicits strong opinions on both sides. Those who argue against mandatory training often cite the...
Against Banning Dark Patterns
The question of whether dark patterns in digital design should be banned is one that demands careful consideration of competing values: consumer autonomy, commercial freedom, and the integrity of publ...
Against Protecting Minors from Political Advertising
The question of whether political advertising directed at minors should face stronger restrictions is one that demands careful consideration of competing values: the protection of young people from ma...
For Stronger Regulation of Addictive App Design
The question of whether addictive app design should be subject to stronger regulation has become increasingly urgent as digital platforms permeate every facet of daily life. This essay argues that the...
Against More Arts Electives
The question of whether schools should offer more arts electives has gained considerable attention in recent years. Proponents argue that expanding arts programmes fosters creativity, boosts student c...
Against Independent Algorithm Audits
In the rapidly evolving landscape of digital governance, the call for independent algorithm audits has gained considerable traction among policymakers and civil society groups. Proponents argue that s...
Against A Longer Lunch Break
The proposal to extend the school lunch break has gained traction among some educators and parents, who argue that additional free time would improve student wellbeing and foster a stronger sense of c...
The Case for Teaching Philosophy in Secondary Schools
In an era of information overload and polarised discourse, the capacity to think critically and reason ethically has never been more imperative. Yet, many secondary school curricula remain conspicuous...
The Essential Role of Media Literacy in Safeguarding Democracy
In a world inundated with digital content, the ability to critically assess media messages is not merely a skill but a democratic imperative. The proliferation of online platforms, while democratising...
For Community Service Before Graduation
The proposition that community service should be a compulsory requirement for high school graduation has gained considerable traction in educational policy debates. Proponents argue that such a mandat...
For A Weekly Club Hour
Should schools set aside one hour each week for student-led clubs? The stronger position is yes: a weekly club hour enriches the school experience in ways that academic classes alone cannot. A persuas...
Against Stronger Data Portability Rights
The debate over data portability rights has intensified as digital platforms accumulate ever greater stores of personal information. Proponents argue that allowing users to transfer their data easily...
Against Clearer Labels on Opinion Pieces
The proposition that opinion pieces should be labelled more clearly online appears, at first glance, to be a straightforward improvement to media transparency. However, a closer examination reveals th...
Against More Shade Trees at School
The proposal to plant additional shade trees on school grounds appears, at first glance, to be an unqualified good. Trees offer respite from the sun, improve air quality, and create a more pleasant en...
Against Compulsory Work Experience
The proposition that work experience should be compulsory for all students has gained traction in educational policy debates. Proponents argue that such programmes bridge the gap between academic lear...
For Buddy Reading Across Year Levels
Buddy reading, a practice where older and younger students read together, offers a range of benefits that extend far beyond simple literacy improvement. This persuasive argument contends that schools...
For More Student Input into School Rules
The question of whether students should have greater input into school rules is one that strikes at the heart of educational philosophy. While some argue that authority must remain centralised for eff...
For Protecting Student Climate Protest
The question of whether student climate protests should receive stronger legal protection has become a defining issue in contemporary democratic discourse. While some argue that such protests disrupt...
For Fruit for Every Child at Recess
Every school should provide fruit at recess. This simple policy can improve children's wellbeing, promote fairness, and build healthy habits that last a lifetime. While critics raise concerns about co...
For More Outdoor Learning Spaces
The modern classroom, with its fluorescent lights and regimented rows of desks, has long been the default setting for education. Yet a growing body of research suggests that confining students indoors...
Against Libraries Open After School
The proposition that school libraries should remain open after school hours appears, on the surface, to be an uncontentious proposal. After all, who could argue against providing students with additio...
Against Restricting Political Microtargeting
The question of whether political microtargeting should be restricted has become a flashpoint in debates about democratic integrity. Proponents argue that microtargeting enables campaigns to manipulat...
Against Stronger Youth Mental Health Funding
The proposition that governments should substantially increase youth mental health funding appears, on the surface, both compassionate and prudent. After all, rates of anxiety and depression among ado...
For A Stronger Right to Explanation
Should automated decisions come with a stronger right to explanation? This question has become central to debates about algorithmic governance, fairness, and democratic accountability. In an era where...
For Mandatory Deepfake Labelling
The rapid proliferation of synthetic media, particularly deepfakes, poses an unprecedented challenge to public trust and democratic discourse. Deepfakes—hyper-realistic audio, video, or images generat...
Against Later Starts for Older Students
The proposal to delay school start times for adolescents has gained traction among educators and health advocates, who cite research on circadian rhythms and sleep deprivation. Yet a closer examinatio...
For Privacy-First Age Assurance
The question of whether age assurance systems should prioritise privacy by design is not merely a technical one; it strikes at the heart of how democratic societies balance competing public goods. On...
The Case for Banning Predictive Policing Algorithms
In the name of efficiency and crime prevention, law enforcement agencies across the globe have begun deploying algorithms that predict where and when crime will occur. These systems, often marketed as...
For Mixed-Age Mentoring
The proposal that schools should establish mixed-age mentoring programs, in which older students guide younger peers through academic and social routines, has generated considerable debate. While some...
For Oral Presentations in Assessment
The debate over the weighting of oral presentations in student assessment has intensified in recent years, with proponents arguing that spoken communication is a fundamental skill undervalued by tradi...
Against Independent Journalism Funding
The proposition that independent journalism should receive stronger public funding appears, at first glance, to be an unassailable good. After all, a well-informed citizenry is the bedrock of democrat...
Against A Weekly Art Afternoon
Should schools set aside an entire afternoon each week for art? Proponents argue that such a block nurtures creativity and wellbeing, but a closer look reveals significant drawbacks. The core mission...
Against Recycling Bins in Every Classroom
The proposal to place recycling bins in every classroom appears, at first glance, to be an unqualified good. After all, teaching environmental responsibility is a worthy goal, and making recycling con...
Against More Practical Life Skills Lessons
The proposition that schools should expand their curriculum to include more practical life skills lessons has gained traction among educators and parents alike. Proponents argue that students emerge i...
Against Restricting Fast Fashion Advertising
The proposition that fast fashion advertising should face stronger limits appeals to environmental concerns and ethical consumerism. Yet a closer examination reveals that such restrictions may be misg...
For Assembly Roles for More Students
Should more students lead parts of assembly? This question has sparked debate in schools across the country. I believe that expanding student roles in assemblies is a wise decision that fosters confid...
Against More Local Excursions
The proposition that schools should increase the frequency of local excursions appears, on the surface, to be an appealing one. Proponents argue that such trips make learning tangible, foster communit...
Against More Youth Spaces in Communities
The proposition that governments should invest more in youth spaces appears, at first glance, to be an unassailable good. Who could argue against providing young people with safe, dedicated areas for...
Against Mandatory Climate Risk Disclosure for Companies
The proposition that companies should be compelled to disclose climate-related risks in standardised public reports has gained considerable traction among regulators, investors, and advocacy groups. P...
The Imperative of Compulsory Voting in Federal Elections
Australia has long prided itself on being a robust democracy, yet the question of who participates in the electoral process remains contentious. At present, voting is compulsory for enrolled citizens,...
For Guest Speakers Every Month
Should schools invite guest speakers every month? This question divides educators, parents, and students. Some argue that frequent visitors disrupt routines and strain budgets. However, a closer exami...
For Platform Accountability for Misinformation
The question of whether digital platforms should bear greater accountability for the spread of misinformation has become one of the defining civic challenges of our era. As social media companies incr...
For Climate Action Days at School
The proposition that schools should hold regular climate action days has gained traction in educational discourse, yet it remains a subject of vigorous debate. This essay argues in favour of such init...
The Case for Mandatory Civic Service
In an era marked by deepening social fragmentation and political polarisation, the notion of mandatory civic service for young adults has re-emerged as a provocative proposal. Critics decry it as an i...
Against Device-Free Lunch Breaks
The proposal to mandate device-free lunch breaks in schools has gained traction among educators and parents who argue that such a policy would foster face-to-face interaction and reduce screen time. H...
For More Student Choice in Reading
The question of whether students should have greater autonomy in selecting their reading materials within the school curriculum has sparked considerable debate. Proponents argue that choice enhances e...
Against Banning Energy Drinks Near Schools
The proposal to ban the sale of energy drinks near schools has gained traction among parents and health advocates, who cite rising concerns about adolescent health and academic performance. While the...
Against a Daily Screen-Free Lesson
In recent years, a growing number of educators have proposed that schools should protect one screen-free lesson every day. The idea sounds appealing: a break from digital devices might encourage more...
For the Mandatory Inclusion of Indigenous Australian Perspectives in the National Curriculum
The Australian education system has long been criticised for its singular perspective on the nation’s history and culture. Too often, the curriculum presents a narrative that marginalises the voices a...
Against Open Access to Publicly Funded Research
The proposition that publicly funded research should be made openly accessible to all has gained considerable traction in recent years, championed by advocates who invoke principles of equity, transpa...
Against Celebrating Effort More Than Winning
In recent years, many schools have shifted their focus from celebrating winning to praising effort. While this approach aims to build confidence and resilience, I argue that it ultimately undermines t...
Against More Cooking and Food Lessons
The proposal to expand cooking and food lessons in schools has gained traction among advocates who argue that such programs foster practical life skills, promote healthier eating habits, and build con...
The Imperative of Mandatory Mental Health Literacy in Senior Secondary Curricula
In recent years, the discourse surrounding adolescent well-being has converged on a troubling consensus: the mental health of young Australians is in decline. Rates of anxiety, depression, and self-ha...
For Limits on Cashless School Systems
The question of whether schools should limit fully cashless systems is not merely a logistical one; it strikes at the heart of equity, access, and the purpose of public education. While proponents of...
For More Projects and Fewer Exams
The debate over how best to assess senior secondary students has intensified in recent years. Critics of traditional examinations argue that they measure only a narrow band of cognitive skills, often...
For Optional National Digital Identity
The question of whether national digital identity systems should remain optional is not merely a technical debate; it is a fundamental test of how a democratic society balances efficiency with individ...
The Case for Compulsory Civics Education in Australian High Schools
In an era of declining voter turnout, rising political polarisation, and the proliferation of misinformation on social media, the question of whether Australian high schools should mandate civics educ...
Against More Debate and Public Speaking
The proposition that schools should allocate more time to debate and public speaking has gained traction among educators who champion student voice and critical thinking. Yet a careful examination of...
The Case for Advanced Persuasive Literacy as a Core Senior Skill
In an era defined by information saturation and algorithmic curation, the ability to critically evaluate and construct persuasive arguments has become not merely an academic asset but a civic necessit...
Against Mandating Digital Literacy as a Core Subject
The proposition that digital literacy should be mandated as a core subject in every school curriculum has gained considerable traction among policymakers, educators, and technology advocates. At first...
For Formal Argument Skills for All Students
The question of whether all students should be taught formal argument skills has become increasingly pertinent in an era marked by polarised public discourse and the rapid spread of misinformation. Th...
For Weekly Persuasive Speaking Practice
Should every class set aside time each week for persuasive speaking practice? I argue that it should, because regular spoken argument builds essential skills that benefit children in lasting ways. A s...
The Imperative of Civic Education on Compulsory Voting
In the Australian political landscape, compulsory voting is a distinctive feature, yet many young Australians enter the electorate without a thorough understanding of its history, mechanics, and ethic...
Two Ways to Begin Again
Beginning again is a universal human experience, yet the way we restart is never neutral. The decision to rebuild, reform, or reinvent is shaped by two invisible forces: context and power. Context inc...
What a Difficult Task Teaches
When we encounter a difficult task, our first instinct is often to focus on the immediate struggle: the hours of practice, the frustration of failure, the sheer effort required to push through. Yet wh...
Comparing Quiet and Loud Courage
Courage is often imagined as a dramatic, visible act—a soldier charging into battle, a whistle-blower facing a tribunal, or a protester standing before a line of police. These images dominate our cult...
The Value of a Second Draft
In the rush to complete a first draft, writers often prioritise getting ideas onto the page over considering the broader implications of their words. Yet it is in the second draft that the true craft...
A Year Measured in Questions
As the year draws to a close, it is natural to look back and ask what we have truly learned. In Year 12, the curriculum often presents knowledge as a set of facts to be mastered, but the most enduring...
Learning from a Mistake
Every mistake carries a story, but that story is never told in isolation. When we examine a misstep—whether in an exam, a relationship, or a professional decision—we tend to focus on the immediate err...
Why Small Habits Matter
In the final weeks of the school year, as the summer heat settles over the classroom and the last assessments are handed back, it is tempting to measure progress in grand gestures. We remember the maj...
Comparing Speed and Patience
In a world that often celebrates rapid progress, the tension between speed and patience becomes a question of context and power. Speed can signal efficiency, decisiveness, and control—qualities prized...
The Best Evidence for Growth
Growth is a term we often celebrate, but what constitutes the best evidence that it has truly occurred? Too frequently, we rely on simple metrics—higher test scores, increased profits, or faster compl...
How Feedback Changes Work
Feedback is often imagined as a simple exchange: one person speaks, another listens, and improvement follows. Yet anyone who has sat through a year of essays, peer reviews, or even casual comments kno...
A Summary of Three Choices
Every decision we make, whether in writing, in politics, or in our personal lives, is shaped by two forces: the context in which it occurs and the power dynamics at play. Context provides the setting,...
The Difference Between Help and Rescue
In everyday language, the words "help" and "rescue" are often used interchangeably. We say we helped a friend with a difficult assignment, or we rescued a colleague from a looming deadline. Yet beneat...
What Makes a Goal Worth Keeping
Consider two students at the same selective school: one from a prosperous family with a home library, tutors, and a parent who works flexible hours; the other from a single‑income household where ever...
Comparing Rules and Responsibility
Rules and responsibility are often presented as opposing forces: rules constrain, while responsibility liberates. Yet this binary oversimplifies their relationship. In practice, rules and responsibili...
The Lesson Inside Disagreement
Disagreement often feels uncomfortable, even threatening. Yet it is one of the most powerful engines for learning, provided we are willing to examine not just the opposing view but the circumstances t...
How Confidence Is Built
Confidence is often described as a personal quality, something that resides within an individual. Yet this framing overlooks the crucial roles of context and power in shaping who feels confident, when...
A Reflection on Fairness
Fairness is one of those concepts that seems simple until you try to define it. Most people would agree that being fair means treating everyone equally, but life rarely offers such neat solutions. A t...
Comparing Memory and Record
Every day we rely on both memory and record to make sense of our lives. Memory offers a personal, lived version of events, coloured by emotion and perspective. Record, on the other hand, implies a fix...
Why Endings Need Care
Endings are rarely simple. They carry the weight of everything that came before, yet they also stand alone as final impressions. To understand why endings need care, one must first consider the contex...
The Shape of a Strong Explanation
Every strong explanation begins with a decision about what to include and what to leave out. This act of selection is never neutral; it is shaped by the explainer's context and the power dynamics at p...
What Reading Changes
Reading is often described as a private act, a silent conversation between a reader and a page. Yet this description overlooks the forces that shape both the text and the person holding it. Every book...
Comparing Success and Progress
In many classrooms and workplaces, success and progress are often treated as interchangeable terms. A student who achieves high marks is said to be successful, while one who improves steadily is descr...
The Role of Evidence in Opinion
Every opinion we hold, whether about a political candidate, a scientific claim, or a personal decision, is built on evidence—but the type of evidence we accept is rarely neutral. In a courtroom, eyewi...
How a Community Remembers
Every community remembers, but no community remembers everything. The act of collective memory is inherently selective, and the selection is never neutral. Context—the historical moment, the social en...
A Reflection on Attention
Attention is not merely a cognitive function; it is a form of currency that shapes our understanding of the world and our place within it. In an age of constant digital interruption, the ability to di...
Comparing Private and Public Voices
Every person speaks in more than one register. The voice we use when talking to ourselves in the mirror differs from the voice we use in a job interview, and both differ from the voice we use when arg...
Why Revision Matters
Revision is often misunderstood as a simple act of correction—fixing typos, smoothing awkward sentences, or adjusting punctuation. Yet for Year 12 students preparing to leave school, revision offers s...
The Question Left Open
Every argument, every decision, every piece of writing leaves something unsaid. The question left open is not a failure of logic or a gap in evidence; it is the space where context and power quietly s...
How to Weigh Two Texts
When we set out to compare two texts, the instinct is often to line them up side by side, looking for similarities and differences in content, structure, or style. But this surface-level approach miss...
The Most Useful Lesson
Every lesson we carry forward from school is shaped by the circumstances in which we learned it. A mathematical formula might seem abstract until you use it to calculate the trajectory of a soccer bal...
A Polished Final Thought
As the year draws to a close, we often pause to consider what we have learned and how we might express that understanding in a single, polished thought. But what makes a thought truly polished? It is...
