Skip to content

- Emily Dickinson

You know that Portrait in the Moon --

So tell me who 'tis like --

The very Brow -- the stooping eyes --

A fog for -- Say -- Whose Sake?

...

Read full poem

noun

A decorated cloth hung at the back of a stage.

Know more
1,153 words~6 min read

The Advice I Outgrew Slowly

When I was thirteen, my father summoned me into his study after a particularly disappointing maths exam. He closed the door with a soft click, then told me that the secret to earning respect was never letting anyone see you struggle. At the time, the words felt like armour, a protection against the shame of falling short. I nodded, memorising the lesson as if it were a chemical equation etched into my skull. His face was earnest, backlit by the green desk lamp, and I understood that he was passing down a survival strategy he had refined through decades in a competitive industry where vulnerability was treated as a liability. The advice was clean and simple: appear unruffled, and the world will assume you are competent. I took it to heart, believing that vulnerability was synonymous with failure, and that I could simply will myself into ease by performing a flawless exterior. That night, I rehearsed the concept in the mirror, practicing the calm, unaffected expression I would wear from then on, like an actor learning a role.

Throughout Year Nine, I became a virtuoso of concealment. I stayed up past midnight drilling trigonometry into my tired brain, but in class I yawned theatrically and murmured that I had been distracted by a novel. When a teacher asked if I understood a concept, I nodded without hesitation, trusting that I could unravel the textbook later. The chasm between my inner confusion and my outer composure widened daily. I recall one Thursday afternoon in the library, staring at a physics problem set with a hollow feeling in my chest. I was unwilling to raise my hand because that would mean admitting I was lost. Instead, I copied the answer from a classmate's page and felt a brief, illicit relief, followed by a deeper, quieter shame whose edges I could not name. My father's advice was working exactly as intended, but I sensed a cost accruing that I could not yet articulate, a faint erosion of something essential.

The façade crumbled during a group project in Year Eleven. We were building a model ecosystem, and I was assigned to calculate population dynamics. I had no idea what I was doing, but I nodded confidently when the group asked if I was on track. The night before the deadline, I sat alone at the kitchen table, sheets of graph paper scattered around me, trying to reverse-engineer formulas from the textbook while the clock ticked past midnight. When my partner called to check progress, I lied and said I was almost done. The next day, the presentation was a disaster. My calculations were wrong, and the group's grade suffered. My teammates were confused and frustrated; I could not explain without revealing the pretence I had maintained for months. That afternoon, walking home under a grey sky, I felt the advice cracking: the armour had become a prison, and I had locked myself inside.

I stayed up past midnight drilling trigonometry into my tired brain, but in class I yawned theatrically and murmured that I had been distracted by a novel.

The incident forced me to reconsider the value of appearing invulnerable. Over the following months, I observed classmates who openly asked for help during class and seemed to learn faster for it. A new English teacher, Ms Chen, invited us to share our drafts-in-progress and praised the act of revision as a kind of courage. She spoke about intellectual humility as a strength, not a weakness. I resisted at first, but I began experimenting: in economics, I tentatively raised my hand to admit I was confused about supply and demand curves. The teacher did not scorn me; she nodded and re-explained the concept without judgement. No one laughed. That small act of honesty felt like stepping through a door I had forgotten was there. Gradually, I started to see that my father's advice, while protective, had been shaped by a different era. He grew up when appearing invulnerable was often the only viable strategy for someone with his background. But my environment valued collaboration and iterative learning. The advice was not evil; it was simply incomplete.

Unlearning the advice was a slow process, akin to shedding a skin that had fused over years of habitual performance. I had to consciously practise vulnerability. In physics, I started asking the questions I had earlier suppressed, even when my voice wavered. In group work, I admitted when I was stuck and discovered that others were often stuck too. The first few times felt excruciating, as though I were confessing a secret shame. But each time, the outcome was not disaster but often genuine connection. I remember the relief of a lab partner saying, 'Me too, I had no idea,' and then working through the problem together. Slowly, the fear of being seen as struggling loosened its grip. I began to understand that competence was not a fixed state I had to perform, but a process I could participate in openly, with all its messy trial and error. The old advice felt increasingly like a garment cut for a smaller self.

By my final year of school, I had developed a different approach to learning and collaboration. During an extended essay project, I chose a topic I found genuinely difficult: the economics of microfinance in developing regions. I knew I would need help. I scheduled regular meetings with my supervisor to discuss my stumbling points, sent rough drafts weeks early, and welcomed critical feedback. When a classmate asked why I was still working on it so close to the deadline, I said honestly that I was learning as I went. The afternoons in the library, spread with articles and annotated spreadsheets, became a kind of workshop. I no longer hid the pages of notes I had taken. When my supervisor pointed out a flaw in my reasoning, I did not defend a confident stance; I listened and revised. The final essay earned a good mark, but more importantly, I experienced a sense of ownership I had never felt when projecting a flawless image. The process had been visible, and so had my growth.

Looking back, I do not resent my father's advice. It had served him, and it gave me a survival strategy when I had no others. But I outgrew it slowly, not by rejecting it entirely, but by layering new understanding on top. The advice assumed that struggle was a sign of inadequacy, but I have since learned that struggle is a sign of real engagement. The performer's mask I wore so diligently hid my genuine progress from myself most of all. Now, I try to let others witness my uncertainty, not because I seek sympathy, but because I have come to believe that the most authentic competence is the one that acknowledges its own growing edges. The advice I outgrew taught me how to survive; learning to outgrow it taught me how to live more fully, with the courage to be seen as I actually am, in all my incomplete and striving humanity.